about these men and their actions, but few people know of another hero, even
in his native region, whose actions in the War of 1812 were equal if not
superior to those of either Jackson, Harrison or Perry.
Thomas Macdonough of Delaware was the hero of the Battle on Lake
Champlain.
Lewis C. Vandegrift in 1894 told the following story.
"An American Women in England, soon after the War of 1812, was
discussing with an Englishman the merits of the opposing sides. The
Englishman was somewhat more brusque than gallant, and insisted that the
lady's compatriots did not fight fairly, like brave men, but, on the
contrary, gained their advantages over the English by fighting from behind
trees and stumps, like the Indians, to which unfair criticism she retorted
effectually by asking if there were any trees and stumps in Lake
Champlain."
By the summer of 1814, this was from the American standpoint had become
one of defense against a greatly superior British force. According to Alfred
Thayer Mahan, one of America's foremost naval historians, it was
believed that the British wished to make the northern lakes British
waters, to which the Americans should have only commercial access. This
was to be done to weaken any American advantage toward future attempts to
invade Canada. Napoleon had fallen, for the first time, and the British
government was asking about the United States: "Are we prepared to
continue the war for territorial arrangements? Is it desirable to take the
chances of the campaign and then be governed by circumstances?"
This was the policy followed, but the hope of success dimmed when
Thomas Macdonough destroyed the British fleet on Lake Champlain. Except at
Baltimore and New Orleans (the other major battles near the close of the
war), which were more defensive successes, nothing but calamity befell the
American military units.
"To the Battle of Lake Champlain it was owing that the British
occupancy of United States soil at the end of the year was such that the
British occupancy of the United States soil at the end of the year was
such that the duke of Wellington advised that no claim for territorial
cession could be considered to exist, and the basis upon which it was
proposed to treat, was untenable."
Thomas Macdonough was born on December 31, 1783 at The Trap, Delaware,
which the Post office Department in 1844 changed to Macdonough. He was
sixth of the ten children born to Mary Vance Macdonough and Major Thomas
Macdonough, physician, military officer in the Revolutionary War, and
judge of the State of Delaware.
The military tradition was carried on in the family when an older
brother, James, enlisted in the Navy and served on the Constellation in
our difficulties with France just before 1800. In the battle with L'Insurgente,
in which the Americans were victorious and only one was killed and two
wounded, James lost one of his legs.
Through the influence of Senator Latimer of Delaware, Thomas received
an appointment as midshipman from President John Adams on February 5,
1800. Thomas' first cruises were to the West Indies, where the more or
less undeclared war with France continued. Although after these cruises
his ship was sold, the Navy reduced, and many officers dismissed, through
the influence of C.A. Rodney of Delaware he continued in the service.
Macdonough then joined the Constellation for Mediterranean duty in the
Tripoli War. He was transferred to the famous Philadelphia but escaped the
fate if the crew and ship which was captured, when just prior to this sad
event he was ordered as second officer to board the captive Morrish
vessel, Mirboka. Upon return of the Mirboka to the proper authorities, he
joined the Enterprise under the command of Captain Stephen Decatur. He
took part in the two daring and exciting exploits of Decatur-the burning
of the captured Philadelphia and an attack on the Tripolitan gunboats. He
was among those especially mentioned for gallantry in later action.
Macdonough stayed in the Mediterranean service for two more years,
taking command of several vessels before being ordered to Middletown,
Conn., to help supervise the construction of naval vessels. Later on he
served on such ships as the Wasp, John Adams, and the Essex. In 1810 he
was given a type of furlough and ordered to make a voyage in the Merchant
Marine. According to a grandson of Macdonough's, it was on this voyage
that the future hero had a run-in with the British. In Liverpool a British
pressgang seized Macdonough and tried to impress him in the British Navy,
which was a rather common practice during this period, and one of the
reasons we soon declared war on Great Britain.
Despite Macdonough's protests that he was an officer of the American
Navy, the British meant to keep him. He was able to escape, however, by a
daring plan and rejoin his own ship. The next morning as Macdonough sailed
by the British ship he is supposed to have remarked to himself: "If I
live, I'll make England remember the day she impressed an American
sailor." When the war was declared two years later, the rallying,
"No Impressment," had special significance to Macdonough.
Shortly after the war was declared in 1812, Macdonough returned to
active duty and was ordered to take command of the fleet on Lake Champlain
in upper New York State. He had the difficult task of outfitting a small
fleet and maintaining a superiority of naval strength over the enemy. It
was not an easy task when it necessitated moving most of the materials and
seamen from the sea coast to the interior, several hundred miles distance.
According to Mahan, at the beginning of the hostilities the balance of
naval power on Lake Champlain rested with the Americans and this remained
true until about June 1813. The forces of both sides were rather small and
neither made a serious attempt to obtain a marked preponderance. However,
in June 1813 the British caught the Americans in a "trap" and
superiority on the lake passed to the British, and remained so until May
1814.
Return to Delmarva Heritage Series article index